| Collegiate Players | ||
| Erika Lloyd | Converse College | 2007 |
| Bri Scalf | Converse College | 2007 |
| Gabby Berini | Union College | 2008 |
| Gloria Kemp | Embry Riddle | 2008 |
| Mikalee Monachino | Central Missouri | 2010 |
| Lexi Henriott | FSCJ/Belmont Abbey | 2012 |
| Sarah Ragland | Palm Beach Atlantic | 2013 |
| Bailie Burkins | Stetson University | 2014 |
| Nicole Williams | Indian River State College | 2014 |
| Ebony Powers | Georgia College | 2015 |
| Kenzie Breuklander | Broward College | 2015 |
| Madison Sheffield | Santa Fe College | 2018 |
| Alexia Kuehl | Colorado University | 2018 |
| Player of the Year | ||
| Lexi Henriott | Record/Times Union | 2012 |
| Sarah Ragland | Record | 2013 |